The top reason given by Executives actively searching for a new opportunity is their current company misrepresented the job on the front end.
1.) Lose your biases when writing the job description.
Time and time again, we see hiring managers miss getting the top Executive for their position because of hiring manager biases. An example of this bias are hiring managers that state MBA required. Good hiring begins with accessing current and future capabilities, current expertise and past job success as the first sorter. Education should be considered as a backend requirement as part of a holistic review of the candidate.
Many companies are moving away from using degree requirements as the most important qualification. “Academic qualifications will still be taken into account and indeed remain an important consideration when assessing candidates as a whole, but will no longer act as a barrier to getting a foot in the door,” …. Maggie Stilwell, Ernst and Young’s managing partner for talent” (1)
2.) Before you can hire the employee you need, you must define clear responsibilities for the position you are hiring the candidate to fill.
Executives tend to be movers and shakers: the get it done employee. Never discussing more than the general job description with no defined resources and timelines leads to Executive disengagement. Many hiring managers switch into the salesman mode once they find a candidate that they are interested in hiring. It is tempting to pass over the specifics of the heavy lifting involved in the job and focus on general goals. If you have target deadlines, then share with the candidate those deadlines and the resources they will have to accomplish the stated goal. Or if you are needing someone to lead and keep the status quo, tell the candidate. But also, be clear on what aspects they will be judged on in their review.
3.) Don’t hire on gut instinct alone.
Bringing your personal biases to the table can keep you from hiring the best Executive for the job. Hiring the right Executive is a complex decision. According to Harvard Business Review, “The more complex the situation, the more misleading intuition becomes.” (2) Do not jump to quick decisions in the first few minutes of an interview. Both the candidate and interviewer can have off days. Take time to dig deep into specific job performance goals and finding out what is in the candidate’s tool kit to achieve these goals.